Captive Insurance Gains Momentum Among Contractors as New Options Emerge

Categories: NewsPublished On: October 26th, 202616.9 min read
SHARE

PHOENIX, Ariz. — Captive insurance, long a niche tool for construction companies, is picking up speed, and an industry expert expects the pace to increase through 2027 and 2028.

“Right now, I feel like 2026 and 2027 and beyond is as if the water is boiling and the lid’s about to pop off, but in a good way,” said Eric Pach, Captive Practice Leader at INSURICA.

Group captives, in which businesses with similar safety and risk management cultures pool their risk, first took hold in the 1980s and 1990s, Pach said. They were created in response to the medical malpractice insurance crisis, and contractors began joining them soon after. Growth since then has been gradual, he said, “like a pot of water on the stove.”

Pach said more than 50% of companies large enough to qualify for a captive have now joined a group captive. Contractors who haven’t looked into joining a captive risk being left in the standard insurance market with less-safe companies, a dynamic the industry calls adverse selection.

“You’re getting into a market where most of the good companies are now in captives,” he said.

Members of a group captive share expenses and losses, and they can pool purchases of services such as claims management and risk management technology. But Pach said each member remains accountable for its own results.

“The individual member has the most amount of accountability for their own losses,” he said. That accountability encourages members to protect their employees, control vehicle use and choose drivers carefully, which benefits the whole group, he said.

Some older programs have expanded significantly. Pach pointed to American Contractors Insurance Group (ACIG), which started in 1981 and now has grown into an A rated carrier offering out of the box coverages such as subcontractor default insurance and contractors controlled insurance coverage, among other products. Another group, Envision Captive Consultant’s Phoenix Captive (Oklahoma), a heterogeneous contractors’ captive is implementing a new risk control technology to be launched in 2027 and adopted a $5 million primary limit with AXA in March 2026.

Pach said that members saved over a $1,000,000 in premium buying the excess coverage through the Phoenix captive, because the first layer of excess is typically the most expensive layer.

Large contractors with single-parent captives are also finding new ways to assume risk, Pach said, including through reinsurance.

“Reinsurance is a tool for insuring insurance companies, and since captives are insurance companies, it’s a great way for them to access new markets to gain capacity,” he said.

Pach highlighted parametric reinsurance, in which coverage is triggered when an independent, data-driven variable reaches a set level.

“In most cases, it pays for lost income,” Pach said. “Contractors could use it to address risks they can’t insure today or that cost too much to insure, Pach said, including weather, geopolitical or economic changes that could hurt revenue and profit.”

Pach said he expects new coverages, techniques and risk management tools to emerge through both group and single-parent captives.

“If we continue to do those things well, we help keep employees safe to come home to their families,” he said. “We help businesses become more successful in their projects, their operations, their profits, and we continue to build our great nation.”

Eric Pach has a focus on building insurance, risk financing, and risk management programs for businesses. For more information, contact Eric Pach today.